My response, with bullet points. See, there are sometimes I enjoy bashing someone over the head with examples that do fit their generalizations:
The Star Tribune is now owned by a rightwing billionaire,
Who
bought it after the Star Tribune found a surefire way to lose money:
Alienate roughly half of your potential readers with the likes of Lori
Sturdevant, Doug Grow, Nick Coleman, and the despicable Steve Sack.
who "balanced" the Strib's op-ed pages with movement conservatives and centrists in lieu of liberals
Liberals
like the names mentioned above? By the way, what is wrong with balance
in the op-ed section? Successful media acknowledges a diversity
opinion among potential readers/listeners/viewers (* ahem * Fox News
Channel)
If it was once true, it hasn't been the case for well over two decades
Which is why (REDACTED) hardly ever has examples of media bias-- Oh wait...
The media is wrapped around the Right's little pinkie, and someday the more honest conservatives among you will admit to this.
Yes, we've got the media so wrapped around our pinkie, that:
-
in 2000, the media called the state of Florida for the Democratic
presidential candidate when the polls were still open in the panhandle, a
traditionally Republican-dominated part of the state.
- in 2004, a reporter tried to discredit a sitting Republican president with documents that couldn't be authenticated
-
in 2008, reporters spent more time vetting a Republican
vice-presidential candidate than they did the Democratic presidential
candidate.
- in 2012, in the aftermath of the Aurora, CO movie
theater shooting, and ABC News' Brian Ross identified a James Holmes who
was a member of a Tea Party chapter in Colorado. He had no
confirmation this was the shooter and had to retract his comments when
it turned out he had the wrong Holmes.
- in 2012, a debate moderator
committed an arguably-unethical act in backing up the incumbent Democrat
during a presidential debate. Worse yet, she got her facts wrong.
Just a few examples of how the Right has got control of the media. /sarc
My little citation of examples of how the media is not controlled by the right wing earned me accolades from some of my like-minded commenters. It's not why I do it, but it's nice to get the virtual pat on the back every once in a while.
Now, unlike some, I don't spend every moment on the comment boards. I figured if my debate opponent had a response, he would respond to me, which would translate into an email notification.
The thing is, he didn't respond to me. He responded to someone else and "refuted" my examples:
1. Al Gore won Florida but didn't have the guts to fight the fix that was in.
2.
George W. Bush walked away from duty but because of a Republican
operative's ability to make the argument be about a side issue, Bush
wasn't held accountable for going AWOL.
3. Sarah Palin adopted her
youngest child. No clue what that was about but she's active in a crazy
church and is never held accountable for her truly extremist views. I
grew up in rural Iowa so please don't tell me hers are rural views
because that defames all rural people.
4. ABC is a very Republican friendly network. I'm sure Ross was punished for slipping up.
5. Sorry, can't unpack that one. I need a name or a date or something to go by.
I
comment under my own name and I am proud to be an American, but it
shames me as an American when otherwise good Americans think democracy
requires vote suppression like in Communist countries.
The biggest
shock to me after moving to Minnesota in 1988 was that 1) the Star
Tribune was not the liberal newspaper I thought it was, just another
pro-corporate, pro big business daily; 2) that the Star Tribune kept
visibly moving to the right, yet the insults from the hard right just
grew more vicious even as they grew less factually based; 3) that the
Star Tribune evolved into an outright Republican newspaper, yet still
was abused by MN Republicans who by then had moved all the way into the
John Birch Society camp (and I grew up reading John Birch Society
literature and do know it when I read it).
The MN Republican party
is now bankrupt having elected leadership that talked hard right but
governed as kleptocrats and borrowed what they could not raise. They
couldn't beat Al Franken (seriously, how hard was that?) because they
couldn't do better than to run a former Democrat who had his suits paid
for by an Iranian businessman.
But I will vouch for Ultra. He
sounds exactly like a MN Republican: unwilling to let facts get in the
way of his beliefs. Sadly, MN will keep reelecting people like Al
Franken until such time as MN Republicans start trying to win instead of
insisting on ideology first and foremost.
Of course, this happened a month ago, so I missed the whole exchange and comments on the thread are now closed. He and I have both gone on to comment on other blog posts. But when I saw this today, I smiled and shook my head. I shouldn't be surprised. And this blog doesn't get the visibility of others. So this response is less for any audience, but more a catharsis for me.
Let's dissect this:
1. Al Gore won Florida but didn't have the guts to fight the fix that was in.
The thing is, he didn't. You have no proof. And by the way, what does this have to do with media bias? Try to stay on topic, please.
2.
George W. Bush walked away from duty but because of a Republican
operative's ability to make the argument be about a side issue, Bush
wasn't held accountable for going AWOL.
Again, where's your proof? Dan Rather and Mary Mapes levelled accusations against a sitting Republican president with documents that couldn't be authenticated, especially when it looked like they were typed in Microsoft Word in 2004, and not like they were typed in 1973 on an IBM Selectric typewriter. Once again, however, my point was about media bias. You seem to want to debate historical events. It's possible Bush was AWOL. But the thing is,
you can't prove it! Neither could Dan Rather or Mary Mapes, which is probably why they fired/forced to resign: They made inflammatory accusations based on shoddy "evidence." Journalists must be held to high standards.
3. Sarah Palin adopted her
youngest child. No clue what that was about but she's active in a crazy
church and is never held accountable for her truly extremist views. I
grew up in rural Iowa so please don't tell me hers are rural views
because that defames all rural people.
Good Lord, do you have a learning disability? My point was how the media spent so many resources trying to dig up dirt on Palin in Alaska, when they couldn't be bothered to look into Obama's past. I said nothing about her children or her views. Further, I didn't say anything about how Palin's views reflected rural values, or anything like that, but maybe my super-secret straw man filter wasn't on. By the way, I have visited rural Iowa, and I can confidently express this: You don't speak for rural people, either.
4. ABC is a very Republican friendly network. I'm sure Ross was punished for slipping up.
Really, you're sure? That's your defense? Isn't he still working at ABC? Seems to me his punishment wasn't severe enough. Like I said, journalists should be held to high standards. When your job has the potential to endanger a person's like or livelihood, a suspension doesn't necessarily cut it.
5. Sorry, can't unpack that one. I need a name or a date or something to go by.
Well, if you'd responded to
me, I could've clarified my example for you: I was talking about CNN's Candy Crowley and when she moderated one of the debates between Obama and Romney. In a blatant unprofessional move, Crowley interjected into the debate to correct Romney and side with Obama. Turns out, Romney had his facts right, and Crowley was mistaken. Even if it went the other way, she should have not stepped out of her role as a debate moderator. She gave Obama an unfair advantage in the debate-- he should've been the one to correct Romney!
Then there was this gem:
I
comment under my own name and I am proud to be an American, but it
shames me as an American when otherwise good Americans think democracy
requires vote suppression like in Communist countries.
I'm sorry, what was the point of this? Was this a dig at me? Does my use of a pseudonym negate the validity of the points I made? Maybe I've seen enough stories of people exercising their free speech rights and getting subjected to various forms of retaliation. Why does it matter to you? Did I thwart your plans of trying to make the debate personal? Good, because debates shouldn't be about the people in the debate, they should be about the ideas.
By the way, who brought up vote (fraud) suppression? I mean, besides you? Once again, you're probably lucky I didn't see your response until it was too late. I'm not sure your psyche could withstand the public trouncing.
The biggest
shock to me after moving to Minnesota in 1988 was that 1) the Star
Tribune was not the liberal newspaper I thought it was, just another
pro-corporate, pro big business daily; 2) that the Star Tribune kept
visibly moving to the right, yet the insults from the hard right just
grew more vicious even as they grew less factually based; 3) that the
Star Tribune evolved into an outright Republican newspaper, yet still
was abused by MN Republicans who by then had moved all the way into the
John Birch Society camp (and I grew up reading John Birch Society
literature and do know it when I read it)
Where to begin? If this guy thinks the Star & Sickle is a right-wing newspaper, I'm guessing he thinks Lenin was a moderate! By the way, I read his crack about MN Republicans moving all the way into the John Birch Society as "Republicans to the right of Arne Carlson, the only Republican governor the DFL ever halfway liked." And he grew up reading JBS literature, huh? Funny how he can't distinguish from viewpoints to the right of William F. Buckley, and the viewpoints of the Tea Party, which is as far right as the S-T could (theoretically) go. Or does my opponent think the Star Tribune should look a little bit more like the Worker's World Daily?
The MN Republican party
is now bankrupt having elected leadership that talked hard right but
governed as kleptocrats and borrowed what they could not raise. They
couldn't beat Al Franken (seriously, how hard was that?) because they
couldn't do better than to run a former Democrat who had his suits paid
for by an Iranian businessman.
The thing is that Norm Coleman did beat Al Franken. On election night. It wasn't until the recount produced a
statistically unlikely reversal under the supervision of SoS Mark Ritchie, a politician whom was supported in his run by ACORN, an organization that "accidentally" ran afoul of various laws, including those pertaining to voter registration, more than once. And I'll point out that Coleman was an incumbent U.S. Senator running for re-election against Franken. Coleman had won in 2002 after populist Paul Wellstone died in a plane crash five days before the election, and the DFL scrambled to put Walter Mondale in his place. The polls showed Wellstone in the lead, and voter sympathy should've made it a landslide for Mondale. But then there was that memorial-turned-political-rally that so disgusted voters that they voted for Coleman out of spite. Coleman's bad fortune in 2008 was the wave of anti-Bush sentiment among voters.
But I will vouch for REDACTED. He
sounds exactly like a MN Republican: unwilling to let facts get in the
way of his beliefs. Sadly, MN will keep reelecting people like Al
Franken until such time as MN Republicans start trying to win instead of
insisting on ideology first and foremost.
Seems to be the first rule of debate if you're losing as badly as this guy: Attack your opponent! For the record, asshole: Yes, I did live (past-tense) in Minnesota. Yes, I tended to vote Republican. No, unlike you, I'm not only open to new facts and information, but I'll actually cite them when making my argument. The only "beliefs" I hold are related to my faith.
And pardon me, but stuff your unsolicited advice: What is it with leftists and their need to advise their opponents on "how to win"? Evidence to date shows running Republicans as Democrat-lite is a consistently-doomed approach. In 2010, we saw what happens when the GOP runs on its principles (not ideology, moron: Ideology implies the gulf between Republicans and Democrats as akin to Capitalists and Marxists).
Yesterday, the author used the example of a plumber to illustrate how wages should be set by market forces, and not by some bumbling government bureaucrats. The gist of the post was how the plumber is a skilled laborer, one whom can charge more for the service of fixing a leaky pipe than a fast-food cashier or burger-flipper.
Enter Dog Gone and her cognitive dissonance:
OK, not all plumbers are unionized. And even the ones that are, in fact, skilled laborers: They spend years learning the trade, be it from vocational schooling, apprenticeship, or some combination thereof. They have to acquire the skills somehow. When they take their licensing exams, or whatever plumbers do to get licensed, they have spent considerable time learning their trade. The licensing just says that knowledgeable people in their field have evaluated the plumber and deemed him or her as competent enough to upgrade your plumbing without flooding the basement.
So you admit that the job requirements are low. In other words, the job is a low-skill or unskilled labor. Answer me this: When an overqualified person takes a job, does the employer pay for the employee's skills, or the work product they produce?
Which is why said person should learn a marketable skill and/or gain experience so they can justify the higher wage he or she earns, in line with the quantity and quality of the work product he or she outputs.
To compare low-skill and unskilled jobs with high-skill jobs is the false equivalency.
Why do progressives always whine about unfair life is? Did they not hear or heed that lesson from their parents? Yes, it sucks that people with college degrees are flipping burgers. But I would ask what sort of degrees these people have that they can't effectively market themselves in an economic downturn. I would ask if they had a plan "B" for when their niche degree failed to land them a good-paying job. My ex-girlfriend sat for and passed the Minnesota Bar Exam in 2007, along with 600 other new lawyers. She quickly learned that in the legal business, it's not about what you know, but who. She clerked for a judge for a lot longer than is common before securing a junior prosecutor position, or associate position at a law firm. Ultimately, she moved to Texas and is working as an insurance agent now, a far cry from her goal of being an intellectual property attorney. She learned that in Minnesota, with some 500 new lawyers being admitted to the bar every six months, that supply simply outstripped demand for her skill set.
Come now, you don't get to make blanket statements and then not back them up. How are conservative policies at fault? The sub-prime mortgage fiasco is partly the responsibility of reckless lending, encouraged by a meddlesome government that thinks it's unfair that some people can't buy houses. Again, life is not fair. In its attempt to create fairness, both the government "watchdogs" and predatory/reckless lenders not only failed to help people buy houses and stay in them, but the policies resulted in a sudden dumping of real estate on the market. Great if you're a first-time home buyer with the means, lousy if you're a homeowner responsibly paying his or her mortgage, only to suddenly end up upside-down on the mortgage when your house loses a huge chunk of its value.
Who sets this adequate wage? Who defines what adequate is? The dollar value? What criteria are used to determine this value? What mathematical formula? How much emotion goes into it?
The determination of this value, I've always felt, is a contractually-negotiated number between employee and employer. That's what capitalism is. That's what free enterprise is. What makes the enterprise free is that the employer is free to decide what wage he or she is willing to pay to an employee for the work product, and the employee is free to negotiate for more or seek employment elsewhere.
Every time the minimum wage is raised, the employers operating on the thin profit margins have a couple of options: Raise their prices, which endangers the business' life expectancy; Fire employees to cushion against the increased labor cost (and likely replace the employees with automation); or close their doors. In two of the three scenarios, employees end up as beneficiaries of those same subsidies you're trying to get them off of, only now there's more of them.
Wow, quite the arrogant statement. What makes you an authority on how a specific business runs, and how many local, state, and federal laws they're required to comply with to stay in business? But I'm not surprised: Progressives are enigmatic mixture of arrogance with benevolence (in spending other people's money that is).
Other countries may be able to do that, but in this country, that's called age discrimination. If a fast-food joint has a choice between a teen and a senior citizen, which do they hire? The senior citizen who's likely to have a more business-like attitude and work ethic? Or the teenager with the energy to work the longer or harder shifts and ability to learn how to more quickly work the cash register?
The thing is they are not in direct competition. Wal-Mart and Costco cater to different groups of customers. Here is an excellent dissection of that false equivalency, courtesy of Forbes: http://www.forbes.com/sites/lauraheller/2014/06/29/walmart-and-costco-are-not-the-same/
Well, an employer who requires unskilled or low-skill labor does.
Paying people what they're actually worth, instead of what someone arbitrarily decides they're worth, is a failure?